Hey, Ken, Thanks for resubmitting this assignment. Wow this time you got the rocks looking really good. Now they look more like rugged rocks. They are a little busy but you did such a good job I would much rather you leave them as they are and not mess with them. Also the waves are greatly improved and now the entire painting is in good shape. The main thing I want you to work on now is your blending technique. Your work is a little choppy and rough. It will take time but you need to really work on making more subtle transitions from color to color and value to value. Then your work wont look so choppy. Plus your work will appear more professional. I feel really confident that you are improving enough that you can move on to the next assignment. So congratulation. Cant wait to see how you are going to handle the next assignment. God bless you and stay inspired.